Are Backpacks Better Than Messenger Bags

Are Backpacks Better Than Messenger Bags

The new fashion season gives us a massive selection of bags, shoulder bags, backpacks, and handbags. Let’s focus today on more practical options – backpacks and messenger bags. Many people consider that rucksacks are only sporting things. Therefore, most of them cannot take such accessories in all situations. For example, someone does not use a backpack for work, office, parties, and dates.

On the contrary, someone considers a backpack stylish anywhere. After all, now, there are many different styles of bags. We can use the accessory in various areas of our lives. It took a worthy place among the essentials. It is well if you can buy several bags for different purposes. What to do if you need to make a choice? Are backpacks better than messenger bags? Let’s find out. I will try to consider in detail all the pros and cons of both accessories. I hope my advice helps you make the right decision.

Messenger Bags vs. Backpacks: Making the Right Choice

There are a vast number of bags varieties. In everyday life, we want to feel comfortable. Is not it? But how often do we prefer practical and convenient things? The pursuit of fashion can kill our individuality. The convenience and moral satisfaction will only emphasize it. Do you agree with that? When choosing the right solution, it is essential to consider many points, such as manufacturer, material, capacity, price, and type. So, what is better messenger bag vs. backpack for back health?

People’s opinions often differ. It all depends on tastes, preferences, etc. Quite often, irresponsible people carry the same bag to the store, office, and beach. It can be the same for using on the beach and in the office. But you will need a bag with wide straps in the store. Narrow belts constrict blood vessels, which negatively affects blood circulation. The same goes for backpacks.

There are a lot of talks and controversy on Reddit about the bags. Some point to the nice style of the messenger bag, others to the convenience and practicality of the rucksack. However, we need to find out the pros and cons, the benefits of two types of accessories


Backpacks pros and cons


  • Ease of use.
  • Ease of movement.
  • Mobility and freedom of action (free hands).
  • Practicality and ergonomics.


  • Not very convenient in transport and crowded places.
  • Discomfort in winter.
  • The sick back is not for a backpack.
  • Inconvenience in hot weather.

Messenger bags

Messenger Bags pros and cons


  • Stylishness.
  • Large selection of models.
  • Convenience.
  • Versatility.


  • The threat of posture.
  • Not suitable for difficulties.
  • Not comfortable in hiking, sports.

Is a Messenger Bag Better Than a Backpack: Use in Different Situations

Improper carrying of the bag can harm your health. Similarly, the wrong choice for various situations can affect convenience and practicality. I will help you understand in which case and for what purpose it is better to choose a bag or backpack.

For college

When you choose between a backpack or messenger bag for college, I think it’s better to give preference to a backpack. Rucksacks (for example) are deservedly considered the best choice for students. Unlike a variety of bags, they are the most convenient to use. The main advantage is that the mass of things is evenly distributed. The student can avoid injuries and back pain. You need to take the bag with the wide regulatory straps. This is necessary so that the belts do not overwhelm the vessels. They also provide freedom of movement and excellent capacity.

For cycling

If you are a cyclist, then you cannot do without a backpack. It will free your hands for cycling and will contain everything you need. The bag does not limit you to movements and actions. It is easy and simple on any road surface.

For travel

Both accessories have their pros and cons. However, I think that a backpack is best for travel. I used my backpack to study when I was a student. But for some reason, I never had the idea that I can travel with it. On moving to distant lands, I was always going with a small suitcase or travel bag and messenger bag. But the last year I travel only with a rucksack: it’s convenient, and everything is with you.

For hiking

Backpacks are the basis of any adventure, hike, trip designed for a long time. Hiking is the most wide-spread type of rest. So you need a small backpack and a camera in hand. Any rucksack and the most straightforward sports shoes will suit you. You can carry the necessary things and equipment with maximum comfort. Modern travel backpacks have a functional design, made using advanced materials, have many useful accessories and details.

For work

For such purpose, a messenger bag is best for business people who choose a classic style. Bags are practical for placing a laptop, documents without worrying about bending, damage, and change its shape. In addition to convenience, the bags look elegant and stylish. I consider the combination of work and backpack incompatible. However, of course, if you don’t work in the office or you can afford a backpack, then choose your style.

For photography

Do you work with a camera, or do you enjoy making photography? Then you better give free rein to your hands and buy a backpack. The accessory will hold all the necessary things wherever you go. You can travel, ride the bus, walk, and still take photos. Your items are always with you. And your hands are busy with your favorite hobby.


And Finally

So what to choose? In some cases, such choice depends not only on appearance but also on health.

Regarding the backpack:

  • Recently, rucksacks have become quite a popular accessory among girls and guys.
  • I find that the backpack is more practical, more comfortable compared to the bag.
  • I do not recommend a rucksack for people who have back problems.
  • If you need to store and carry a large number of different items, a knapsack will help you.
  • In addition to a stylish appearance, these accessories are also useful for health, unlike the bags.
  • The students of all ages must use a briefcase.

Regarding the messenger bag:

  • The bag is suitable for any style because such an accessory is famous for its diverse design.
  • It is always versatile and looks more stylish.
  • You can quickly open it and get all the things you need.
  • If you are going on a business trip, then a bag will suit you better.

I believe that people shouldn’t compare these things. Both will come in handy in life, and both will have their advantage in wearing. The most important item is that you like the thing and be comfortable. Do you agree with me? I advise you to purchase several different kinds of bags for various purposes. The modern market proposes a huge variety of rucksacks and bags models. Thus, everyone can choose the best option for professional use.

Marion Humble

Marion Humble

Welcome to my blog. Call me Marble. Now I live in Chicago and work as a courier. Every day I use different types of backpacks. In this blog I want to share my experience in the selection and proper care of backpacks. About me.

Add comment